George Slater of Keoghs successfully defended a high-value credit hire claim in Clerkenwell and Shoreditch County Court. The claimant sought £132,012.78, comprising £111,401.98 in credit hire charges and £20,530.80 for storage and recovery. At trial, the court awarded £3,286 in total, a reduction of more than 97%.
The claimant, a taxi driver and bailee of the vehicle in question, sought hire charges for 261 days at a daily rate of £417.82. In addition to his taxi work the claimant was employed by Tesco and thus had an additional and consistent revenue stream. At trial, the claimant indicated that he needed access to a vehicle in order to commute to this additional place of work which was accepted by the trial judge as a reason not to limit the claim to loss of profit.
Impecuniosity was a central issue in the case. The claimant relied on numerous bank statements, tax returns and profit and loss accounts in support of his pleading. Following challenge by Keoghs, the judge found that the claimant had sufficient funds available to contribute to the cost of repairs and rejected the plea of impecuniosity. Indeed, it was notable that the claimant’s available cash balance actually increased by several thousand pounds during the relevant period.
In addition, there were notable discrepancies in the claimant’s apparent earnings and the amounts declared to HMRC within his tax submissions. The claimant’s explanation that this was a mistake by his accountants was far from convincing and somewhat concerning. There is no doubt this added to the judge’s finding on the issue of impecuniosity.
That impecuniosity finding was also relevant to the recoverable hire period, which was reduced from 261 days to eight weeks.
The claimant’s evidence in support of the £417.82 daily hire rate was also challenged. Having considered the basic hire rate (BHR) evidence, the judge assessed the recoverable rate at £35.71 per day. Because the available comparator rates were quoted in four-week blocks, the court awarded an eight-week period when applying the BHR evidence.
The claimant had also purchased an excess reduction waiver via the CHO. The court made no separate award for that element because it did not reduce the excess to nil and did not provide additional value beyond the claimant’s own motor insurance excess.
As for the storage charges, they were dismissed in their entirety. The judge found that the claimant had suitable off-road parking at home and that the damaged vehicle did not present a danger if kept there, given the limited nature of the visible damage. Recovery charges were limited to those associated with transporting the vehicle to the repairer and for local authority inspection post repairs.
The decision demonstrates the importance of testing each component of a credit hire claim. Detailed analysis of the claimant’s financial evidence, the claimed hire period, the daily rate and the need for associated storage enabled the defendant to achieve a substantial reduction in the award. This result is a timely reminder of the evidential burden that the claimant alone has to prove their case, especially when concerned with a claim of this size and nature.

Designed to elevate the policyholder experience and empower handlers, ClaimPilot transforms the claims journey with state-of-the-art AI, streamlined processes and reduced operational bottlenecks – all in one powerful platform.
